Summer in Utah means two things: outdoor adventures and home renovations. With average remodeling projects in the state running between $42,000 and $47,000 in 2026, that kitchen overhaul or basement finish isn’t just a lifestyle upgrade — it’s a serious financial commitment. And here’s the part most homeowners miss: your standard homeowners insurance probably isn’t covering you the way you think it is during construction.
Two-thirds of American homeowners are currently underinsured, according to industry data, and that gap only widens when contractors start swinging hammers. Before you sign that contract or pick up a sledgehammer yourself, here’s what you need to know to protect your home, your wallet, and your sanity.
Free: Utah Family Coverage Checklist
Get the 7 coverages every Utah family should have.
Why Your Standard Homeowners Policy Falls Short During Renovations
Your homeowners insurance was designed to protect a finished, occupied home from sudden and accidental damage — things like fires, storms, and burst pipes. It was never built to handle the chaos of an active construction zone. Here’s what a standard policy typically won’t cover during a renovation:
- Theft of building materials and tools stored on-site
- Damage from construction activities (a contractor accidentally breaking a water line)
- Structural damage during demolition or framing
- Injuries to unlicensed workers on your property
- Gradual deterioration from an exposed renovation site left open to the elements
Even worse, some insurers may consider a major renovation a material change to the property’s risk profile. If you don’t notify them before work begins, they could deny a claim entirely — or cancel your policy.
The Underinsurance Trap
Here’s the scenario that catches most people off guard: You finish a beautiful $60,000 kitchen remodel with custom countertops, high-end appliances, and new cabinetry. Six months later, a kitchen fire causes significant damage. You file a claim, only to learn that your dwelling coverage limit was never updated to reflect the renovation. Your home’s replacement cost jumped by $60,000, but your policy didn’t. You’re on the hook for the difference.
This is called the underinsurance gap, and it happens far more often than you’d expect. Even mid-range upgrades — a new bathroom, replacement windows, a finished basement — can push your home’s replacement value well above your current coverage limits.
What You Need: A Pre-Renovation Insurance Checklist
Before a single nail gets hammered, take these steps to make sure you’re properly protected.
1. Call Your Insurance Agent Before You Start
This is the single most important step, and the one most homeowners skip. Notify your insurer about the scope of the project, the estimated cost and timeline, whether the home will be occupied during construction, and who is doing the work. At The Insurance Box, we do this review for free — it takes 15 minutes and could save you tens of thousands.
2. Verify Your Contractor’s Insurance
Before you hire anyone, ask for a Certificate of Insurance (COI) that shows general liability insurance (minimum $1 million per occurrence), workers’ compensation coverage for all employees and subcontractors, and that the policy is current. If a contractor’s employee gets injured on your property and the contractor doesn’t carry workers’ comp, your homeowners policy — and your personal assets — could be on the line.
3. Understand Builder’s Risk Insurance
For major renovations — generally anything exceeding 10% of your home’s value — you should seriously consider a builder’s risk insurance policy. It covers theft of uninstalled materials, damage to the structure under construction, and soft costs like architect fees and permit costs.
Builder’s risk premiums typically run 1% to 5% of your total project budget. For a $50,000 renovation in Utah, you’re looking at $500 to $750. One important note: if you’re living in the home during the renovation, you’ll need a Permission to Occupy endorsement added to the policy.
4. Update Your Dwelling Coverage Limit
Don’t wait until the renovation is complete to adjust your policy. Contact your agent to increase your dwelling coverage during the project, not after. After the project is done, schedule a formal coverage review to recalculate your home’s replacement cost based on square footage added, quality of finishes, and new systems installed.
5. Document Everything
Take dated photos and videos before, during, and after the renovation. Keep receipts for all materials and labor. Store copies of permits, contracts, and your contractor’s COI. If you ever need to file a claim, this documentation is the difference between a smooth payout and a denied claim.
Renovations That Impact Your Insurance the Most
Not all remodels affect your insurance equally. Swimming pools can increase your liability exposure significantly — expect a premium increase of 5% to 10%. Basement finishes add $20,000 to $60,000 in value. A new roof can actually lower your premium with impact-resistant shingles. Kitchen and bathroom remodels averaging $40,000 to $75,000 in Utah are the most common source of underinsurance. Home additions directly increase replacement cost and almost always require a coverage adjustment.
Common Mistakes That Lead to Denied Claims
- Hiring unlicensed contractors. Utah requires contractors working on projects over $3,000 to be licensed. Unlicensed work can lead to denied claims.
- Skipping permits. Unpermitted work can void your coverage. Always pull the required permits.
- Not notifying your insurer. Failing to disclose a renovation can result in claim denial, coverage gaps, or policy cancellation.
- Assuming your contractor’s insurance covers everything. Their liability covers damage they cause. It does not cover your belongings, pre-existing structures, or post-project claims.
Utah-Specific Considerations
Utah homeowners face unique factors when renovating. Standard policies typically exclude earthquake damage — if you’re renovating on the Wasatch Front, consider earthquake coverage. Homes in Utah’s wildland-urban interface may face additional scrutiny. The dry climate increases fire risk during construction with exposed framing and sawdust. And many Utah communities have HOA rules about renovations, including insurance requirements for contractors.
The Bottom Line: 15 Minutes Can Save You Thousands
A summer renovation should be exciting, not financially devastating. The difference between a smooth project and an insurance nightmare often comes down to one phone call before work begins.
- Call your insurance agent before signing a contractor agreement
- Get a Certificate of Insurance from every contractor
- Consider builder’s risk insurance for projects over 10% of your home’s value
- Update your dwelling coverage during and after the renovation
- Document everything with photos, receipts, and contracts
Not sure where to start? Take our free coverage quiz to see if your current policy is ready for your renovation plans. Or book a free consultation with one of our agents.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does homeowners insurance cover home renovations?
Standard homeowners insurance provides limited coverage during renovations. It may cover sudden accidental damage like a fire, but it typically won’t cover theft of building materials, construction-related damage, or injuries to unlicensed workers. For major projects, you’ll likely need additional coverage like a builder’s risk policy.
How much does builder’s risk insurance cost in Utah?
Builder’s risk insurance typically costs 1% to 5% of your total project budget. For most Utah renovations, expect to pay around $0.85 to $1.50 per $100 of project value. A $50,000 renovation would cost roughly $500 to $750 to insure.
Do I need to tell my insurance company about a remodel?
Yes — always. Failing to notify your insurer about a renovation can lead to denied claims, coverage gaps, or policy cancellation. Call your agent before work begins, not after.
What happens if my contractor doesn’t have insurance?
If an uninsured contractor causes damage to your property or a worker is injured on-site, you could be held personally liable. Always verify your contractor’s general liability and workers’ compensation coverage before hiring.
Should I increase my homeowners insurance after a renovation?
Absolutely. Any renovation that increases your home’s value should be reflected in your dwelling coverage limit. Failing to update your coverage means you could be underinsured if you need to file a claim.
What renovations increase homeowners insurance the most?
Swimming pools, home additions, and finished basements tend to have the biggest impact on premiums because they significantly increase your home’s value and liability exposure. Kitchen and bathroom remodels also require coverage updates but may not increase premiums as much.